Manchester United are addressing the wrong problem position

Man Utd have signed Noussair Mazraoui from Bayern Munich in their latest defensive addition.

It was always inevitable Manchester United would sign a new right-back after they agreed to sell Aaron Wan-Bissaka to West Ham United.

Luke Shaw, Lisandro Martinez and Kobbie Mainoo of Manchester United in action during a first team training sessionplaceholder image
Luke Shaw, Lisandro Martinez and Kobbie Mainoo of Manchester United in action during a first team training session | Manchester United via Getty Images

Noussair Mazraoui is viewed as a player better suited to Erik ten Hag's style of play than the former Crystal Palace full-back, though it was arguably not the problem position which needed addressing the most in defence this summer.

When fully fit, Diogo Dalot will be expected to start on the right next season, and while Mazraoui will have first-team ambitions of his own, he is hardly a clear upgrade on Wan-Bissaka in the back-up role. It leaves United's backline still rather lopsided in terms of talent. They still have two proven options at right-back, while there are questions marks over every option they have on the left.

Luke Shaw missed the Community Shield clash with Man City last weekend and is a doubt to be involved against Fulham on Friday night. Tyrell Malacia is not due back in training for at least two months and even then there are obvious concerns about his ability to play matches straightaway. Harry Amass could have the potential to play at senior level but is not there yet, leaving Ten Hag overly reliant on the injury prone Shaw.

While both Mazraoui and Dalot can both play at left-back, they are by no means specialists in the position, which leaves United a little light in terms of appropriate cover. It is certainly a risk heading into the season when they were punished so emphatically for a lack of depth last season.

Shaw has only played in 275 out of a possible 561 United matches in his decade at the club, and only made 15 appearances across all competitions last season. On his day he is a world-class specialist in his position, but his days have been few and far between as of late.

United can't afford another season of such uncertainty in a starting position and will hope they are not punished for failing to address what is a growing transfer issue in their squad. If United are also looking to learn from past mistakes, they can't keep settling for short-term fixes either. Though they might have a couple of players who could fill-in at left-back, it is hardly the approach conducive to a successful season.

The addition of Mazraoui shouldn't be sniffed at, but he is not the full-back they needed to sign the most this summer.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice