Ex-Aston Villa star slams Man United over 'harsh' Joshua Zirkzee call and names £57m man as worse offender
Summer signing Joshua Zirkzee was subbed off after just 33 minutes in the defeat to Newcastle United
Manchester United dropped to an all-time low in the league table when they were beaten 2-0 by an exuberant Newcastle United side at Old Trafford.
Goals from Alexander Isak and Joelinton gave Newcastle a comfortable lead after just 20 minutes as the Red Devils were overwhelmed by the intensity of Eddie Howe’s resurgent Newcastle team.
It was a night to forget for several Manchester United stars, as they suffered a first defeat against the Magpies at Old Trafford since 2013.
And it was a particularly difficult night for summer signing Joshua Zirkzee, who was replaced by Kobbie Mainoo after just 33 minutes, in a change which prompted a chorus of audible cheers from the home crowd.
Gary Neville’s reaction to the substitution
“I actually feel sorry for him I really do. I know he’s earning a lot of money, but there’s a human being in there that’s basically being cheered off by his own fans, and it’s brutal.” Gary Neville said on commentary.
“I’ve not seen that too many times at Old Trafford in the 43 years I’ve been coming here, if at all actually.”
How Joshua Zirkzee fared against Newcastle United
Joshua Zirkzee started in the number 10 position behind Rasmus Hojlund and was only able to get 14 touches of the ball before being sacrificed in the first half.
In that time, he completed just three of his attempted nine passes, giving the ball away on seven occasions, whilst failing to complete a single dribble or register a shot at the Newcastle goal.
It was the latest in a long line of disappointing performances for the Bologna star, who has struggled to hit the ground running at Old Trafford since his £36.5m move.
The Manchester United trio that ‘should have’ been subbed first


Speaking after the game at Old Trafford, Gabby Agbonlahor sensationally claimed that there were as many as three Manchester United players that started the game worse than Zirkzee, who were fortunate not to be taken off in the opening 33 minutes.
Speaking about the incident on talkSPORT, the former Aston Villa striker said: “I just didn’t like it, It wasn’t nice. There’s no more embarrassment than being taken off in the first half, it’s worse than being a sub who gets subbed.
“I don’t think he was any worse than [Amad] Diallo was or any worse than [Rasmus] Hojlund. I don’t think he had to take him off. I think he had to take Casemiro or [Christian] Eriksen off and put [Kobbie] Mainoo in there.
“[Lisandro] Martinez should have been dragged after 34 minutes, not make a scapegoat of Zirkzee. Amorim will look back at that and think ‘yeah, maybe it was a bit harsh taking him off after 34 minutes.”
Zirkzee, who has scored four times in 27 appearances, will hope to make a better impression when Manchester United travel to Liverpool in their next league fixture. The defeat left Manchester United in 14th position at the end of 2024, marking their lowest finish to a calendar year in the Premier League era.
