Manchester United star proved Ruben Amorim and Sir Jim Ratcliffe wrong - but it won't change anything
The main talking points as Man Utd faced Athletic Club in the first leg of their Europa League semi-final.
It was Manchester United’s biggest match of the season, and now that honour will be placed on the second leg next week. Ruben Amorim made two changes to his starting line up for the first semi-final meeting against Athletic Club and opted for the shock inclusion of Victor Lindelof.


The Swede is set to leave United as a free agent this summer, but was required to start the massive match, with Noussair Mazraoui repurposed to a wing-back role and Luke Shaw not fit enough to start the clash. Amorim might argue he had no other option, but it still felt like a massive call to start someone with no long-term future at the club.
Even if United qualify for the Champions League, Lindelof won’t be a part of that squad, but he is a big reason why those dreams are still alive. The 30-year-old struggled in the early exchanges of the match but redeemed himself in some style with a vital goal-line clearance that had a huge impact on the result. United might need better, but he did what was required of him on the night.
United might need to sign the perfect partner
The midfield battle was always going to be a key factor in the first leg, and what will have alarmed Ruben Amorim is that it felt like a Premier League match before the red card. United had more possession than many expected, but they struggled with the intensity of the Athletic Club press and made far too many unforced errors.
Casemiro maintained his improved European form, though there were some concerns with the performance of Manuel Ugarte and how he struggled to match the tempo of the clash. It is particularly alarming given Casemiro is the player United want to replace this summer after they signed Ugarte for £42 million a year ago.
The Uruguayan has formed a key part of the side under Amorim, though there are still concerns about his shortcomings and whether he is suited to English football. You only have to look at the success Paris Saint-Germain have had since they replaced him with Joao Neves. United want to sign another central midfielder this summer, and the right addition could bring the best out of Ugarte. If they do that, it could be like having two new midfielders in the side.
A luxury United can’t afford
Sir Jim Ratcliffe cited Casemiro when he referred to some Manchester United players 'who are not good enough' and others who 'are probably overpaid.' The Brazilian stood up to be counted when it mattered the most again against Athletic Club and certainly answered the first part of that complaint.
The money could soon become an even bigger issue. Casemiro took a wage deduction due to United's failure to qualify for the Champions League, but would return to a weekly wage of roughly £350,000-a-week if they go on to win the Europa League. That is a luxury Ratcliffe won't approve of.
Casemiro has been the unsung hero of the Europa League campaign and has undergone an incredible redemption arc under Ruben Amorim, who initially claimed he didn't have the “characteristics” required to play in his midfield. With his experience and expertise, he is still an incredible asset in European football, but there is no escaping the fact he does not have the same impact in the Premier League. He has been a priceless asset in their Europa League adventure, but he is a luxury they can no longer afford.
Amorim might already know his second leg line up
Manchester United were handed a huge boost for the remainder of their season with Matthijs de Ligt and Amad Diallo both back on the bench for their meeting with Athletic Club. They would both be named in United’s best team from the current season and have been sorely missed in recent weeks.
De Ligt and Amad might not have been able to have much influence on the outcome of the first leg result, but with them both set to feature against Brentford this weekend, the hope is they will both be available to help book a place in the final next week. In an ideal world, they could both be in the starting line up for the second leg, but it might no longer be such a risk.
Ruben Amorim could change his side when they host Athletic Club at Old Trafford; it doesn’t mean he needs to if they are to book their place in the final.
Manchester United player ratings: Two 8/10s but 'remarkable' 9/10 'ran the show' in emphatic Athletic Club win
