Manchester United player ratings: Two 8/10s but 'remarkable' 9/10 'ran the show' in emphatic Athletic Club win

Man Utd player ratings from their emphatic Europa League semi-final win over Athletic Club.

Casemiro and Bruno Fernandes led by example as Manchester United thumped Athletic Club 3-0 in the first leg of their Europa League semi-final tie. Ruben Amorim made two changes to his starting line up for the match, with Victor Lindelof and Manuel Ugarte selected from the start.

Manchester United player ratings from the comfortable win over Athletic Clubplaceholder image
Manchester United player ratings from the comfortable win over Athletic Club | Manchester United via Getty Images

United took the lead when Casemiro headed in after a fantastic piece of wing play from Harry Maguire, and things got even better when Fernandes doubled their lead from a penalty that saw Dani Vivian sent off for conceding it. United sensed blood and had a third before half-time when Fernandes finished a fine attacking move in emphatic style.

Casemiro nearly added another when he headed against the post after the restart, and the only complaint United can have is that they only won the match by a three-goal margin. Here is how we rated the players on an exceptional night.

Manchester United player ratings vs Athletic Club

Andre Onana

He made a key save in the first half that ensured United did not go behind. An important contribution to the result deserves recognition. 7

Leny Yoro

Another impressive defensive performance. He started the game well and kept Athletic Club at bay. Some very tidy footwork. 7

Harry Maguire

An excellent performance. He defended brilliantly and produced a breathtaking piece of skill in the build-up to the opening goal. 8

Victor Lindelof

A difficult start to the night, but he redeemed himself with a crucial goal-line block. He grew in confidence as the tie progressed. 6

Noussair Mazraoui

A good showing in the wing-back role and fired a ferocious effort against the bar. He linked up with his teammates well throughout. 7

Manuel Ugarte

It started as a sloppy performance, but he got better. He covered a lot of ground but was poor in possession and gave the ball away too often. 6

Casemiro

His redemption arc has been remarkable. Another brilliant goal and an effortless performance in a midfield battle they dominated. He ran the show. 9

Patrick Dorgu

He could easily have been punished for poor positioning in the early stages. He made some positive attacking contributions to the match. 6

Alejandro Garnacho

A great finish for his disallowed goal. He proved to be a constant threat throughout the match and linked up well with his fellow forwards. 7

Bruno Fernandes

The man for the big occasion again. He twice kept his cool in the first half to give United an emphatic lead and was instrumental in the win. 8

Rasmus Hojlund

He won the penalty that swung the match in their favour. Worked hard for his teammates throughout and offered physicality upfront. A real improvement from him. 7

Substitutes

Matthijs de Ligt

It was great to see him back on the pitch after his recent injury setback. He hardly put a foot wrong during his appearance. 6

Mason Mount

He gave United energy from the bench and broke up play with a couple of fouls. A few sloppy moments in possession and he was booked. 5

Luke Shaw

Amorim saw Shaw as a centre-back but he has been at his best in a wing-back role. He relished the attacking freedom and was calm in possession. He could have had two assists. 7

Kobbie Mainoo

He was calm on the ball and hardly had to break a sweat during his time on the pitch. A brilliant option to have on the bench. 6

Amad Diallo

It was brilliant to see him back on the pitch in the final minutes of the match. He could have a big role to play in the remainder of the campaign. 6

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice