Pep Guardiola might have to rethink key Manchester City selection with first change in seven years
The opening two performances of the new season have raised questions about who should start at right-back.
There was no doubting who stole the show for Manchester City in the opening game of the Premier League season.
Rico Lewis ended the last campaign by starting the final six Premier League matches on the bench and was given less than 20 on-field minutes as City swept everyone aside en route to claiming a fourth consecutive title.
But in the opening weeks of the new season he has very much been front and centre, in a figurative and quite literal sense. Starting at right-back at Wembley and Stamford Bridge, the teenager popped up all over the pitch; in the centre to help City maintain possession, pushing down the line to create an overload and even offering several penetrative runs into the box.
“Arriving in the final third, as a full-back, in the inside channel, how many times? In the pockets, he moves like a player few times I’ve seen in my life,” was Pep Guardiola succinct post-match assessment when speaking to Sky Sports after Sunday’s 2-0 win at Chelsea.
That praise shouldn’t come as too much of a surprise. In January 2023, the City boss claimed Lewis ‘makes the team better’ and in October last year said it was ‘difficult to find’ a player with the youngster’s qualities.
Yet Sunday’s commendation had an additional layer to it, and it was notable that Guardiola also referenced Lewis’ defensive contributions.
“He saved a goal because always he’s in the right position. In the one against ones defensively, he’s unbelievable,” said the former Barcelona boss. “He does everything good, one against one defensively, blocking shots in the first-half from [Christopher] Nkunku, he’s always ready, he moves inside and outside perfectly. Honestly, Rico is a top, top player.”
It could be Lewis’ defensive improvement that ultimately sees him start to play a more prominent role in the City team, although the 19-year-old revealed earlier this summer that he views himself as a midfielder rather than a full-back.
But with the plethora of choices in those roles for Guardiola, including Ballon d’Or contender Rodri and Sunday’s other star performer Mateo Kovacic, the full-back roles are likely to offer Lewis the greatest chance of earning regular minutes this term.
That in itself might bring a slight tactical deviation from Guardiola, who typically uses John Stones or Manuel Akanji to drive into midfield from the heart of defence, rather than the wide areas.
But Lewis’ emergence as a genuine option on the right side of defence could disrupt the status quo in Guardiola’s squad. No outfield player has enjoyed a stronger hold over one specific position in the last seven years than Kyle Walker has at right-back.
The England international has played over 300 games in that time and comfortably held off competition from Danilo and Joao Cancelo for a starting berth, especially with the latter tending to operate on the opposite side of defence.
But at 34, with his performances slowly starting to decline, no shortage of off-field distractions, and on the back of a second transfer window in a row where Walker has been linked with a City exit, this feels like the beginning of the end.
If so, Sunday showed the Premier League champions have a bona fide replacement waiting in the wings. Indeed, there is a growing argument that Lewis can offer Guardiola’s possession-based side more than Walker given his technical abilities, coupled with his enhanced defensive skills.
The real test will come when the City captain is fully back up to speed following his extended summer break, but a legitimate battle for a spot at right-back could be one of the more intriguing subplots of Guardiola’s ninth - and potentially last - season in Manchester.
