Man City have one major problem that no-one is talking about
Pep Guardiola’s lack of squad depth could prove to be a major problem over this season.
Manchester City’s final game before the international break was far from comfortable for the Premier League champions.
Fulham outscored City in expected goals and could, on another day, have netted five. Had Adama Traore brought his shooting boots, City’s nearly two-year unbeaten run at home would surely have come crashing down.
Instead, Mateo Kovacic’s brace and a late piledriver from Jeremy Doku ensured the Blues came away with a slightly fortunate 3-2 win. It meant Pep Guardiola’s post-match press conference centred around City’s defensive record, Ederson’s qualities and his personal relationship with Traore.
But in the immediate aftermath, one major talking point was overlooked. City had named just six outfield players on their bench.
With Premier League clubs able to select nine substitutes, typically eight are outfielders, along with one goalkeeper. But against Fulham, City had one spare spot on the bench, while Guardiola also named two goalkeepers.
For context, both City’s Under-21s and Under-18s were in action that Saturday. Had they not, then Nico O’Reilly would almost certainly have been named in the senior squad along with probably Jacob Wright or Jaden Heskey.
But it’s still a worrying development for City, who were without Rodri, Oscar Bobb, Nathan Ake and Kevin De Bruyne for the Fulham game. The latter pair should be available after the international break, although it’s not impossible both haven’t yet fully recovered.
With Rodri out for the season and Bobb not expected back until January, it means City’s numbers will be depleted until at least the turn of the year. That is a concern, as was the injury Jack Grealish sustained over the international break.
Thankfully, it proved to be a minor knock and he played and scored in England’s 3-1 over Finland, but another absentee could have been a real issue. It also underlined how quickly things can change; players can pick up knocks and niggles in an instant.
There is often a misconception that Guardiola has an abundance of talent at his disposal, that City’s second XI would beat most sides in the league. In reality, Guardiola’s preference to work with a smaller squad could leave the team slightly vulnerable.
For instance, City have eight defenders listed in their first-team squad. One of whom, Josh Wilson-Esbrand, last played for the senior team in February 2022, while Rico Lewis is often deployed in midfield. That leaves City with just six defenders, while Erling Haaland is the only recognised centre-forward in the entire squad.
That posed an issue during the middle third of last season, when Haaland missed two months of the campaign with a foot injury. The 2-1 win against Luton Town in December again exposed the dearth of options on hand for Guardiola, who selected a bench that included two keepers, three defenders, while his attacking options were Kalvin Phillips, Sergio Gomez, Matheus Nunes and Bobb - none of whom had a particularly glowing CV at that stage.
Julian Alvarez provided the solution when Haaland was out last season, an option Guardiola can’t avail of this term. The City boss even acknowledged in August that he could come to regret his decision not to replace the Argentinian.
“Maybe it’s a mistake, I don’t know, but I don’t like to work with not a long squad,” he said on transfer deadline day. “I don’t like to leave players with a long time not playing. When we have long squad and no injuries, it’s months without playing and I don’t like it.”
Guardiola opted against making major additions in the summer window, with just Savinho and Ilkay Gundogan brought into the squad, although he hasn’t ruled out dipping back into the market in January.
For now, City will hope to stay relatively injury-free, as has been the case during the last few seasons. Indeed, there was a period in May this year where Guardiola didn’t have a single injury concern. That’s almost unheard of in the Premier League.
But on other occasions the lack of squad depth has been an issue. At the end of the 2021/22 season, injuries to Ruben Dias, John Stones, Nathan Ake and Kyle Walker left City having to field a makeshift back four in the final games of the season which included Fernandinho at the centre-back. Aymeric Laporte was forced to play with knee pain and subsequently required surgery the following summer. His City career never recovered.
Likewise, a spate of injuries nearly proved problematic during November 2023, when there were questions over the fitness of eight different players.
Ultimately, Guardiola’s modus operandi has resulted in four consecutive league titles, so no-one can question his methods. But in a mammoth campaign that is set against the backdrop of talk of player strikes and burnout, Guardiola’s preference for a smaller squad feels more risky than ever.
Coupled with a season-ending injury to his star man, and there’s already a feeling that City simply can’t afford more than a few more knocks at any one time.
It’s an issue that could prove to be the defining aspect of this season’s title race and potentially Guardiola’s last season in Manchester.
