Exclusive:‘I would sit Ederson down’ - Shay Given reveals his verdict on Manchester City goalkeeper transfer saga

The ex-stopper also gave his verdict on whether Stefan Ortega is ready to be Manchester City’s new no.1.

Former Manchester City goalkeeper Shay Given has told ManchesterWorld that he hopes Ederson stays at the Etihad this season as he remains the best stopper in the world with the ball at his feet.

Shay Given has said he hopes Ederson stays at Manchester City this summer.placeholder image
Shay Given has said he hopes Ederson stays at Manchester City this summer. | Getty Images

The Brazilian has attracted interest from Saudi Arabia this summer and is understood to be keen on a move after seven years at City. Despite that, the Premier League champions are yet to receive a formal offer for Ederson, who they reportedly value at around £50m.

As the 2024/25 campaign draws closer, the goalkeeper position is perhaps the biggest uncertainty surrounding Pep Guardiola’s squad, with just over two weeks until City face Manchester United in the Community Shield. Stefan Ortega played when the sides met at the end of last season in the FA Cup final, and is poised to do so again if Ederson leaves.

However, Given hopes that is not the case and said the ex-Benfica man has plenty more to offer.

“I’m a little bit surprised [with the situation], to be honest,” the Irishman said in an exclusive interview with ManchesterWorld. “Ederson is a brilliant goalkeeper and since he joined in 2017 he has been a huge part of the success. 

“But the Saudi League is a big prospect - plenty of players, including Kevin De Bruyne are being linked with a move there.

“I would be surprised if he [Ederson] goes and I suspect there’s no smoke without fire and conversations are taking place. I would be surprised if City wanted to let him go as he’s that important to how they play.

“From a financial point of view you’re always looking for the biggest fee you can get because they’re trying to balance the books,” Given added, on the possibility of Ederson leaving. “But I don’t know if it’s going for the big fee or sitting him down and saying ‘we don’t want you to go’. 

“I would like him to stay at the club as I think he’s a brilliant goalkeeper. I think Ortega’s a good keeper too, but it massively weakens that department if Ederson leaves.”

“Ortega did well last season and there was some talk about that save against [Heung-min] Son is the reason why he is annoyed. I would be surprised if it was down to one save.”

Shay Given is a brand ambassador for sports betting platform CopyBet.placeholder image
Shay Given is a brand ambassador for sports betting platform CopyBet. | CopyBet

That potentially title-winning stop against Tottenham Hotspur was Ortega’s most telling contribution of a season in which he actually made 20 appearances. That was partly down to injury, but Ederson did remain on the bench for two games in April - including a Champions League quarter-final trip to Real Madrid.

Guardiola has regularly expressed his admiration for both keepers and it would appear that he is more than comfortable with Ortega taking the no.1 spot if Ederson leaves. It’s a verdict Given shares.

“I think he would be ready to step up. He proved that last year, and not with just one or two games, he was in for quite a long spell with Ederson being injured,” said the former keeper, who made 69 appearances for City between 2009 and 2011. 

“Even when he came back, Ederson was on the bench for a few games. I think that shows Pep thinks really highly of Ortega. He’s a brilliant goalkeeper, but I would look at the whole goalkeeping department and if you lose either one of those guys you would have to go into the market to bring someone in.”

Despite Given’s backing, he thinks there is one area where City would undoubtedly suffer if Ortega were to assume Ederson’s mantle.

“I think Ortega is really cool and calm, and can play under pressure. But Ederson is just the best goalkeeper in the world with the ball at his feet - I don’t think there’s any argument about that,” said Given. “He really is that good and when opposition sides have a high press he just misses that out and hits it into [Erling] Haaland, or zigs it 70 yards out to a winger. 

“The pace and power he gets is amazing and I’ve never seen a keeper like it with the ball at his feet. I tell young kids that if they get to a City game to try and get there early and watch Ederson warm up as it’s worth the match fee alone. He’s a real talent and he’s obviously worked at it over his career.”

Shay Given is a brand ambassador for sports betting platform CopyBet. Visit CopyBet.com.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice