Wayne Rooney, Gary Neville and Alan Shearer give Ruben Amorim sack verdict at Manchester United

The Man Utd head coach is under pressure after his controversial comments over the weekend.

Ruben Amorim is under huge pressure to keep his Manchester United job after he questioned the support he has received from the club's hierarchy.

Amorim used the final question of his post-match press conference on Sunday to express his disappointment over a lack of power in his role as 'manager', despite the fact he was hired to be the 'head coach'. In his current job title, Amorim is tasked with leading training and producing positive results on the pitch, but he believes he should be given more freedom to rebuild the first-team squad into one that can play his specific style of football.

Amorim has essentially challenged the United board to back him or sack him, a dangerous ultimatum from a head coach who has only won 24 of his 63 games in charge. The Portuguese boss is due to speak to the media again on Tuesday afternoon and several pundits have already given their take on his controversial comments.

Gary Neville - Sky Sports

"Something has happened in the last week which means that Amorim is starting to unleash a little bit," said Neville on his podcast. “It looks to me that he is not happy with something in the hierarchy. Obviously, something is annoying him, he's obviously not feeling the support. He's obviously letting go. When you say that you came to the club as a manager, I thought he was appointed as the head coach and quite clearly appointed to coach the team.

"Manager is a title that we don't see anymore. Manager suggests that he's saying he wants to manage more than just the training ground performance, he wants to oversee other parts of the club. I played under a manager and they basically have a greater say in what would be other parts of the club including recruitment, academy, style of play, pre-season friendlies and other things. I think he's suggesting that he needs to be given the ability to manage more departments of the club.

“I actually thought against Leeds, defensively United were very strong. I thought they were very solid in the game I thought they handled the atmosphere well. I thought they fully deserved the point out of the game that's why I was surprised at the end to hear of Ruben Amorim's comments because I thought you've got a point away from home.

"You've just had a disastrous result against Wolves at home but there's Burnley to go in three days, there's no real need for a fire right now but there's a fire being created. He's always been authentic, he's always had integrity in his press conferences. He's always said what he believes and he thinks and he should do, he should carry on as he was but it does look like he's now starting to point upwards which ordinarily does bring pressure with it."

Jamie Carragher - Sky Sports

"I don't think he is in any position whatsoever to be questioning the people who appointed him," responded Carragher. "Because he's not good enough. He's not good enough to be Manchester United's manager. He's barely competent enough to be a Premier League manager right now."

"It can only be two things. It can either be about the January transfer market, that he's not being backed. Or the people above him are questioning that he's flip-flopping between systems.

"It started to look like he was getting somewhere with a back four, he went back to a five at the back against Wolves and it was possibly the worst performance from a team we've seen against Wolves this season."

Wayne Rooney - BBC Sport

“It’s strange, interesting,” he told the Wayne Rooney Show. “And I think his choice of words is very, I don’t know, decisive [and] confusing because if you’re a manager or head coach — I don’t know what his title is, as a head coach, I think.

“I think he speaks with a confidence and an authority that he knows he’s going to be there and he’s going to remain the manager and that’s the only reason I can assume he speaks with that belief because the last two games have not been very good. I think it’s quite confusing. I’m confused with the words he said.

“I think you need to earn the right to you need to earn the right to be able to dictate exactly what happens at a football club, especially a football club like Man United. Then, if Guardiola comes into Manchester United, for instance, I don’t think anyone would question what players he wants to bring or bring in or the system. And I just think for Amorim and I actually feel for him a little bit because the squad is not good enough. I said this last week: the squad’s not good enough.

“The players he’s got on the bench are young academy kids, who it’s great to see them on the bench, but are they ready at this moment in time? It’s very difficult to put young players onto a football pitch. When the squad, the team is not very good. I feel for him a little bit, but he is not Pep Guardiola. He’s not Jurgen Klopp. He hasn’t got that history or that background. I don’t think he should be speaking with that authority in [the way] he is. And I just think the words he’s saying are very confusing to me.”

Alan Shearer - The Rest is Football

"Look at his results and record since he’s been at Manchester United, it’s been nowhere near good enough," Shearer said. "I could get [Enzo] Maresca, I get that because of what he’s done and what he’s achieved. But I think he [Amorim] is fighting a losing battle and there’s only going to be one winner.

"It wouldn’t surprise me if he’s not there much longer at all because he just hasn’t got enough in the bank to be coming out and taking the board on like that."

"He’s probably thought, 'I’m going to do it my way, I’m not being told how to play or what to do' which is probably one of the reasons why he said, 'I am the manager, I will do what I want to do and I’m not the coach, I’m the manager and that’s what the agreement was', yet his title is head coach.

"Maybe I’m reading into things… up until the Newcastle game he was adamant in every single interview that he is not changing system and then he went off-piste and changed the system, then the next game went straight back to his own. He’s probably thought, 'I’m not getting any players in January so what’s the point?', and I think that’s maybe what his rant is today."

Manchester United player ratings: 'Tireless' 8/10 but 'smart' star was unsung hero in Leeds draw - gallery

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice