Manchester United can't let £42m signing distract them from Carlos Baleba transfer plan

Man Utd were made aware of their need for a new midfielder in the defeat to Arsenal at the weekend.

If you asked Manchester United supporters to name their transfer priority after the defeat to Arsenal, you can bet most of them would demand a new goalkeeper. Altay Bayindir cost his team in the decisive moment of the match on Sunday afternoon, and there are still doubts over first-choice Andre Onana as well.

At full-time, Ruben Amorim insisted he is happy with the three senior goalkeepers he has at his disposal. Yet the fact United tried to sign Emi Martinez on loan from Aston Villa is an indication he still wants at least one. United made it a priority to overhaul their attack this summer instead, and the performances of Matheus Cunha and Bryan Mbeumo suggest they are on the right track.

It isn't the only problem with their squad, though. United also want to sign a midfielder before deadline day and expressed an interest in Brighton star Carlos Baleba. The South Coast club stood strong and United backed away when it became clear they would have to shatter their club-record transfer fee to get him.

Baleba will now become a top target for their midfield rebuild next summer, but there will surely be an intense fight to sign him after another year in the Premier League. United will target at least two new midfield additions next year, with huge uncertainty surrounding just about every central option currently at their disposal.

Casemiro has entered the final year of his deal and should leave as a free agent at the end of it. His lack of mobility was a problem again in the Arsenal defeat, and it should sound alarm bells that he is still the best defensive midfielder at their disposal. Bruno Fernandes is much better in an attacking midfield role, as is Mason Mount. Kobbie Mainoo lacks the defensive discipline to play alongside the club captain, and Manuel Ugarte has been a dreadful signing.

The Uruguayan looked improved in pre-season against West Ham, but regressed to his former self in a dire performance against Everton. He was poor again against Arsenal, with some clumsy play in possession and a pathetic long-range effort that sailed harmlessly into the Stretford End.

The fact Amorim has been unable to get the best out of a player he worked with at Sporting is one thing; the fact he tried to sign Baleba is another. Yet, with the 21-year-old unavailable this summer, United have been left with a real dilemma. Do they wait a season without a natural central midfielder that could undermine their rebuild, or do they buy a short-term solution to tide them over for another year. Ugarte might provide the answer to that.

United paid an initial £42 million to sign Ugarte from Paris Saint-Germain a year ago and it might take a similar fee to secure a stop-gap before deadline day. That is just about the going rate for a central midfielder in the current transfer climate, even more so if you are Manchester United, looking to buy this late in the summer window.

With no permanent exits sanctioned this summer, it is money they can't afford to gamble. Even if it takes a club-record fee to sign Baleba next year, he is viewed as the perfect fit for their rebuild under Amorim and a player who would be worth waiting for. Casemiro and Ugarte were both signed as stop-gaps after they missed out on priority targets and it makes little sense for United to risk repeating it when they already know who they want.

United need to sign a midfielder, Ugarte is a reminder that they can't just sign any midfielder though.

Two signed, six leave: Manchester United dream end to summer transfer window

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice