Liverpool legend says Man Utd hero would cause nightmares for Premier League rivals - Amorim would be lucky to have him

Manchester United could do with this Old Trafford hero in their side this season, says a Premier League legend

Manchester United have had a mixed start to the new Premier League season and sit right in the middle of the table in 10th place, which is an improvement on much of their time under Ruben Amorim, nevertheless.

Ruben Amorim looks on during Manchester United's victory over Sunderland in the Premier League.placeholder image
Ruben Amorim looks on during Manchester United's victory over Sunderland in the Premier League. | Getty Images

One of the criticisms which has been directed towards the Portuguese during his time as head coach at Old Trafford has been his insistence on playing a two sitting in midfield in his 3-4-2-1 system, despite appearing not to have the players in his squad capable of playing the role effectively.

Bruno Fernandes has been used in a deeper role this season, leading to concerns over his impact on the game lessening from a position in which he is not entirely comfortable. Fernandes often starts alongside Casemiro in the pivot, despite the belief persisting that the Brazilian has lost his legs and is no longer suited to playing in the Premier League. Other younger options such as Kobbie Mainoo and Manuel Ugarte do not appear to be trusted by Amorim, who will wish he had a bone fide Red Devils legend playing in his midfield.

Paul Scholes would be ‘the best midfielder in the Premier League’ in 2025, says Steven Gerrard

Man United legend Paul Scholes would be “hands down” the best midfielder in the Premier League if he played in this era, claimed ex-Liverpool and England captain Steven Gerrard. The former midfielder was appearing on Rio Ferdinand Presents.

“He would have everyone terrorised in the Premier League. I’m telling you right now, he would have everyone terrorised now. He would be the best midfielder in the Premier League, hands down,” said Gerrard.

“Could I be the Steven Gerrard that played in our generation? Could that be now? I’m not sure. I’d have to adapt and I think it would take a lot away from my style. I think Scholesy now, would be the best midfielder in the Premier League, fact.”

“He would be a joke,” interjected Ferdinand.

“I do think that, yeah, because Scholesy, for me, was very much an in-possession controller of a midfield, controller of a game. Can switch the play, you get close to him he can pop it round you, he can play with the outside of his foot, score important goals, make the last pass.

“Scholesy’s thing for me was, can you get him doing the other side of the game? Can you take him the other way, can you be physical with him. He’ll get booked against you. But I’m not sure in today’s game you could leave one on Scholesy.”

Man United legend Scholes remains one of the most respected players of his era

Gerrard’s words come as high praise from a player who was a close rival of Scholes during his playing career. The pair were often compared and contrasted with each other and Frank Lampard, during an era where club rivalry trumped togetherness in the England national team. But according to Gerrard in addition to legendary midfielders such as Xavi and Andres Iniesta, Scholes was one of the very best around.

Scholes’ long list of honours during his illustrious career with the Red Devils needs no introduction. Eleven Premier League titles up to his retirement in 2013, two Champions League wins including the Treble in 1999, with a total of 25 trophies won at the club. Scholes registered 107 goals and 61 assists in 499 Premier League appearances, while it was his control of the game and ability to pass the football which drew him the most praise during the latter stages of his career.

There is no doubt that Ruben Amorim and United would love to have had Scholes playing for them today. His tenacity, heart and pure technical genius could have solved a lot of problems in the Red Devils’ current midfield.

The club will hope that, somewhere in the depths of their academy, there is a young boy inspired by Scholes to develop his game in the Mancunian’s image, ready to someday take to the field at Old Trafford with the aim of emulating his success.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice