Rescheduled Premier League meeting arranged with clubs following Man City APT ruling
Premier League officials are working on a redrafted version of the laws following the results of Manchester City’s legal dispute.
Premier League bosses have pushed back a meeting on Associated Party Transaction (APT) rules to next week.
Both the Premier League and Manchester City are still reeling from the findings of the APT case which were published last week. The three-person tribunal concluded that certain aspects of the rules violate UK competition law, while the decision to block two of City’s commercial deals was deemed ‘not unreasonable’ by the panel.
The three judges also claimed that the decision not to include low-interest shareholder loans in APT laws was ‘unlawful’.
While the Premier League point to the majority of City’s challenges being rejected, the tribunal’s findings mean the APT laws must now be redrafted. An emergency meeting with all 20 clubs had originally been scheduled for this week to discuss how the laws could be amended, but that has been postponed.
Premier League officials had planned to discuss the situation with their legal advisory group and the financial controls advisory group on Tuesday, but with both meetings were cancelled, the decision was taken to push the 20-club consultation back.
Every club has been contacted for feedback on the ongoing APT issues, and Thursday’s postponed meeting has been rescheduled for next Tuesday. It’s understood this will be another opportunity for executives from all 20 teams to share their opinions as part of the consultation period and there will be no vote on the new laws.
Thursday’s shelved meeting comes amid a change of tone from the league’s chief executive Richard Masters, who emailed clubs last week saying he will take ‘the necessary time to develop our proposals and the associated draft rule amendments’. That’s despite the Premier League’s original statement claiming the rule amendments would be implemented ‘quickly and effectively’.
At the heart of the new APT rules will be three fundamental changes: how shareholder loans are valued, the ability to share data on other commercial deals when the league undertakes fair market value assessments, and reverting back to APT rules that were first established in December 2021, prior to the amendments made in March 2024.
It’s not clear at this stage when the revised APT rules will be confirmed, with widespread disagreement among the club as to how the laws should be implemented.
