Pep Guardiola can’t replicate Sergio Aguero solution when Julian Alvarez leaves Manchester City - here’s why

Three years after one Argentinian striker departed the Etihad, another is set to follow suit.

“We cannot replace him,” Pep Guardiola famously claimed when Sergio Aguero departed Manchester City three years ago, the emotional Catalan fighting back tears as he uttered the words during an on-field interview.

He was in some senses correct; Manchester City had lost a bona fide hero, the club’s all-time leading scorer and a man whose unforgettable title-winning goal is now commemorated outside the Etihad. That’s before referencing his personality and character, the more literal meaning behind Guardiola’s words.

Yet in another sense, those claims were a tad inaccurate from the City boss. For a start, no side in England were better equipped to head into the transfer market in search of a free-scoring striker, and the attraction of playing for Guardiola and the English champions would have appealed to plenty of potential recruits.

In fact, Aguero’s departure gave Guardiola the platform to fully implement his latest City masterplan and roll out his striker-less system to its full potential. That approach had been debuted during Aguero’s injury-plagued final campaign with the club, and the forward looked a little clunky in this structure.

Now, with his leading striker leaving, nothing could stop Guardiola from perfecting his new free-flowing system. It wasn’t that City couldn’t replace Aguero, more they didn’t want to.

Three years on and again the club are set to bid farewell to their star Argentinian striker. Julian Alvarez’s imminent departure to Atletico Madrid is both a superb transfer deal and also a significant loss to contend with.

Ironically, Alvarez, a player suited to playing as a no.9 and in midfield, would have slotted perfectly into that fluid striker-less shape. But his arrival in Manchester coincided with another tactical pivot from Guardiola as he reverted back to classic centre-forward in his side.

Alvarez’s exit leaves City and their manager with a dilemma - do they go into the market to find a replacement? And, if so, in which position do they look to strengthen?

Recent reports have suggested the Premier League champions might plump for an additional option in the wide areas, with Pedro Neto cited as an example. Eberechi Eze has also been mentioned as another possible solution, although the Crystal Palace man operates best in an attacking midfield role.

Neither solution seems ideal given City have already strengthened in those positions with the additions of Savinho and James McAtee to Guardiola’s squad over the summer. 

Meanwhile, there have even been suggestions that the ex-Barcelona manager will perform another tactical U-turn and return to his false-nine set up. Yet, there is one major flaw with that approach: Erling Haaland.

Indeed, the arrival of the Norwegian no.9 prompted Guardiola to ditch his post-Aguero methods. For all his obvious talents, Haaland’s skill set does not suit a system of interchangeable attackers. He needs to stay within the width of the posts, sniffing out his opportunistic moment to pounce.

With Haaland around, Guardiola is wedded to his current set-up - he can’t exactly cut out his key man, nor does have any inclination to. So as Alvarez leaves, the most obvious solution is perhaps correct in this scenario. City need a like-for-like replacement.

In this marathon season, it’s imperative that back-up is on hand for Haaland, especially given his injury woes last term. That the 24-year-old suffered with ‘niggles’ during pre-season only amplifies the issue.

An alternative is to implement one system with Haaland, and an entirely different set of tactics without the former Borussia Dortmund star. Yet, that is far from ideal - City can’t perfect two tactical plans, or allow the availability of one squad member to dictate the entire team’s approach.

It’s why City, who have been reluctant to part with any significant transfer sums this summer, will almost certainly have to go into the market during the final three weeks of the window.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice