Manchester City dropped points for the second week in a row as they were held to a 1-1 draw against Newcastle United on Saturday.
In the absence of Rodri and Kevin De Bruyne, City lacked fluidity and creativity for long spells and, despite having most of the ball, failed to sufficiently test Nick Pope throughout the 90 minutes.
Much of the pre-match discussion centred around City’s midfield set-up and how Pep Guardiola would approach the game without the injured Rodri. Never short of a few surprises, the City boss surprisingly opted to deploy Rico Lewis alongside Mateo Kovacic ahead of the back four, with Manuel Akanji pushing into midfield.
City lacked their usual rhythm with the new configuration in the centre but created the better opportunities in the early exchanges as Akanji saw a shot deflected wide before Erling Haaland drew a comfortable stop from Nick Pope when he shot from a narrow angle.
It was a physical contest at St James’ Park with Jack Grealish catching Fabian Schar with an accidental stray elbow before the Newcastle defender picked up a booking for hacking down City’s no.10. Both were among the eight players booked on Tyneside.
But after an opening half and hour that was light on goalmouth action, Josko Gvardiol handed City the advantage in the 35th minute. Collecting the ball from Grealish, the advancing defender cut inside on his right foot and placed a shot beyond Pope and into the bottom corner.
Gundogan failed to make it 2-0 soon after when his chipped effort from distance was caught by Pope, while at the other end Ederson’s quick reflexes denied Joelinton’s powerful acrobatic effort in first-half injury-time.
He was less fortunate after the break, however, as the keeper felled Anthony Gordon in the box as he attempted to win the ball. Referee Jarred Gillett had no choice but to point to the spot, and the England winger converted confidently.
It was a gutsy display from the hosts, whose best chance to extend their advantage fell to Sean Longstaff in the 81st minute.
But it was at the other end where a goal looked most likely, even if City were struggling to cut through a well-organised side for a second week in a row.
Pope had to be on hand to keep out a tame Phil Foden volley, Bernardo Silva’s turn and strike, and then a Haaland header in injury-time. Ultimately, the champions couldn’t find a way past the Newcastle stopper, as City were held again. Here’s how we rated the players...

5. Josko Gvardiol- 7
Improved after a timid start. The defender turned and finished impressively for the goal and took up some dangerous attacking positions at St James' Park.

6. Mateo Kovacic- 6
The deepest of City's midfielders, Kovacic had a tough assignment against a physical Newcastle midfield. The Croat was sharp on the ball and nearly set up Haaland with a well-timed pass midway through the second period.

7. Rico Lewis- 6 (off 81)
Selected to start a Premier League game for the first time in midfield, the youngster played well without having a match-changing impact. Lewis rarely misplaced a pass and regularly helped City advance up the pitch.

8. Ilkay Gundogan- 4 (off 66)
Well below his usual levels. Gundogan had a few sloppy touches on the ball, misplaced a number of passes and will be disappointed with his attempt to chip Pope near the end of the second half.


