How do Manchester City replace the ‘irreplaceable’ Rodri? Four possible solutions to Pep Guardiola’s conundrum
With the midfielder set for a lengthy spell on the sidelines, finding a way to function without their star man will prove problematic for Manchester City.
How do you replace the irreplaceable?
That’s not a philosophical question - much as Pep Guardiola would probably enjoy the readings on such a topic - it’s a genuine query, one that will be troubling the Manchester City manager at present. He may endure plenty of sleepless nights over the coming weeks, tossing and turning as he tries to find the answer as to how his side will play without their star man.
While the full timeline of Rodri’s injury, and how long he'll be unavailable for, are yet to be revealed, Guardiola has already confirmed that the midfielder is set for a prolonged spell without the player he considers to be among the world’s best.
“When a team doesn’t play with the best midfielder in the world for a long, long time, it is a big blow,” the City boss said on Tuesday, in the aftermath of the Carabao Cup victory over Watford.
“But it’s football. It happens. And it is my duty to find a solution, be competitive as we have been for many, many years and be there, be a problem for our opponents.
“Yes, he’s irreplaceable. But I will find a solution. There is an alternative, we will do it. When you have one player who is irreplaceable, as a team we have to find a solution.”
What exactly that ‘solution’ will look like is uncertain, but one aspect of this complex dilemma already looks clear: this won't simply be a case of Guardiola finding an exact replacement for Rodri.
In truth, there might not be one available in world football, let alone in City’s squad. There’s no-one capable of fulfilling the many complicated roles Rodri carries out in the team, be it shielding the back four, dictating the side’s passing rhythm, spraying balls into the wide areas and even popping up with a few goals - he scored nine across last season.
This is more than a personnel change, Rodri’s injury will surely mean an entire shift in City’s tactical set-up.
There are a few ways this could transpire. One would see a defender (probably Rico Lewis or John Stones) push into midfield from defence and help to create an extra option in the middle alongside Rodri’s replacement.
This isn’t a ground-breaking shift for City’s players and it’s a tactic that is regularly deployed by Guardiola. But in this Rodri-less universe, an advancing defender could become a must in every game, which could present some issues when City play the top sides - for instance, Guardiola didn’t utilise such a system in Sunday’s draw against Arsenal.
The progressive defender approach would also mean that Stones - who has started one league match this season - would become more of a regular presence in the side, or Lewis, a player who has been prominent in the team over the opening weeks of the campaign, but it remains unclear if he is definitely part of Guardiola’s strongest XI yet.
Another solution would be to play a double pivot at the base of midfield to provide extra protection for the back four, although that would invariably limit the opportunity for City’s midfielders to get forward. Typically, Guardiola operates with one holder and two others who pour forward at will. This approach even had its issues in opening games of the season when Rodri was out with a hamstring issue, and in the first match of the campaign at Chelsea Mateo Kovacic was left exposed as Bernardo Silva and Kevin De Bruyne advanced.
Two sitters could see a slight shift to a 4-2-3-1 shape, with the wingers pushing inside more often. Other formations such as 3-5-2 or 4-2-2-2 have been utilised previously by Guardiola and a modified version to incorporate Erling Haaalnd also feels possible. Alternatively, playing with a more compact three-man midfield unit would give more defensively solidity, but restrict the side’s attacking potential.
Guardiola may ultimately decide that a tactical reconfiguration isn’t required. Instead, the answer could be to slightly tweak what is required of his defensive midfielder.
In that scenario, Lewis seems the player most suited to filling the void created by Rodri. He has the range of passing, the defensive prowess and is sharp enough in possession to keep the ball moving quickly. Guardiola has also praised Lewis’ in-game intelligence and the teenager seems to just get what his manager requires.
There is one major drawback, though, one regularly mentioned by the Catalan: Lewis’ physical limitations. “He needs to be a bit taller; mum and dad didn't give him much to be taller. Apart from that he has everything,” was Guardiola’s verdict when asked about Lewis’s strengths in October 2023.
Certain alterations would, therefore, need to be made if Lewis is tasked with replacing the 6ft 3in Rodri, and it’s likely the team would rely more on their technical proficiency and less on physical capabilities.
Whatever the solution is, the 2024/25 edition of Guardiola’s City are going to look different to those which came before it. That, most likely, will provide fresh stimulus for a manager who admitted at the end of last season that he wasn’t sure where his next motivation would come from.
Make no mistake about it, retuning this perfectly functioning team will not be straightforward, and there could be a few bumps in the road. But Guardiola tends to find the perfect formula in the end.
