Aston Villa co-owner gives public verdict on Man City’s ongoing APT battle
Manchester City’s legal dispute with the Premier League has resulted in several rules being rewritten.
Aston Villa co-owner Nassef Sawiris has publicly backed Manchester City in their ongoing battle with the Premier League on Associated Party Transaction (APT) laws.
A panel ruled that certain elements of the rules were unlawful and violated UK competition law, in findings that were published at the start of October. In particular, the omission of shareholder loans from the Profit and Sustainability Rules (PSR) was highlighted as an area that must be addressed when the APT laws are redrawn.
That could happen as soon as Friday, less than seven weeks after the initial findings on the independent tribunal, with Premier League clubs set to vote on suggested amendments. This has irked some at City, who feel the new rules are being rushed in and disagree with the decision to not retroactively include club shareholders loans in previous PSR calculations.
And Villa have now come out in support of City, calling on clubs to push back any major decisions on APT laws. In an interview with the Telegraph Sawiris said: “In our view, a vote in 90 days on amended terms taking into consideration the Tribunal’s findings will have a significantly greater chance of securing the unanimous support of all 20 Premier League clubs.
“Crucially, a unanimous vote will present a fresh start for an embattled Premier League that began with the failed attempt to launch a Super League in 2021. With the imminent arrival of the Government’s Independent Football Regulator, it is more important than ever that the Premier League can present itself to the regulator with a united front. In our view, this will be far more easily achieved if the APT vote is held in February and supported unanimously by all clubs.
“It is noteworthy that legal bills to date on this matter have already reached astronomical amounts; further challenges and escalation of these fees could be avoided through reaching consensus.
"Ultimately, a unanimous vote will showcase the emergence of a new era of clubs who can compete vigorously on the pitch but work together to strengthen the Premier League and its global appeal.”
The Premier League’s updated APT rules will be agreed if a majority of 14 vote in favour of the amendments.
