After a month of ins, outs and speculation, the January transfer window slammed shut at 11pm on Thursday evening. It was quiet month among Premier League teams compared to previous years, with concerns over profitability and sustainability rules widespread.
Manchester United and Manchester City were both active in the market, although marquee arrivals were not forthcoming. For Erik ten Hag it was about trimming the fat of his squad with loan exits while Pep Guardiola planned for the future.
The other 18 Premier League teams had mixed fortunes throughout January, with few enjoying news of significant arrivals and many unable to flex their financial muscle. Below, ManchesterWorld has graded the windows of United and City compared to their rivals.

13. Manchester City - C
City spent £12.5m on Claudio Echeverri, who will stay at River Plate until 2025. Definitely one for the future, following the same plans as Julian Alvarez did. Kalvin Phillips on loan to West Ham a notable exit. | Getty Images

14. Manchester United - E
A month of loan exits for United that included Jadon Sancho, Donny van de Beek, Hannibal Mejbri and Facundo Pellistri. No incomings but a short-term striker might have been nice. | Getty Images

15. Newcastle - E
Priced out of a loan deal for Kalvin Phillips amid profit and sustainability concerns. Keeping hold of stars like Bruno Guimaraes a positive but Newcastle could have done with a couple of additions. | Getty Images

16. Nottingham Forest - B
Swooped late to land Giovanni Reyna on loan from Borussia Dortmund after talks with Sevilla broke down. A busy deadline day also saw Rodrigo Ribeiro arrive on loan from Sporting. | Getty Images


