Trafford: My daughter was physically sick when told she would be going to a school miles from Sale home
A mother has told how her daughter was ‘reduced to tears and was physically sick’ after being told she had been denied entry into any of her local secondary schools in Sale.
Lisa Marie Street, 43, is one of about 30 furious parents whose children have been allocated places at Broadoak School in Partington, five miles from where they live in Ashton-on-Mersey village.
She said her daughter, Harriett, 11, was ‘distraught upon hearing the news’.


“It took immense encouragement to get her to school that day, and by the evening she was physically sick from distress,” said Lisa Marrie.
“She struggled to comprehend why she had been denied a place at a school less than a mile away, while being sent to a school in an unfamiliar area.”
“This issue is not just about one child. It reflects a wider systemic failure that is disadvantaging local families and undermining the future of our children.”
She said that following Trafford council’s admissions guidance, she selected Ashton on Mersey and Altrincham College as two of their preferences.
“To our devastation, we were informed [by Trafford council] that Harriett had not been offered a place at any of our chosen schools and was instead allocated to Broadoak in Partington – a school 5.5 miles away, with significantly lower performance standards,” she said.
At a meeting with the Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS), the affected parents said they were stunned to be told their children failed to gain places in any of their FIVE preferred choices of school.
The angry parents have also contacted Altrincham and Sale West MP Connor Rand, who has taken up their case.
The families, who say they have all lived in Ashton village for years, claim the shortage of school places in south Trafford is being made worse because people from outside the borough are renting properties in order to get their children into the best schools.
Trafford council has confirmed that ‘a small number of applicants’ could not be offered places at a school in Sale or Altrincham.
Now, all the parents have told the LDRS that they will appeal.
A petition posted on Change.org by Kate Bader, 42, has gained traction with a total of 1,199 signatures and she has asked Altrincham and Sale West MP Connor Rand for help.
Her post said: “The current high school placement strategy is far from equitable. My own daughter has been offered a place five miles away from home.
“With a surge in the Trafford Grammar Schools Consortium’s exams rate by 13 per cent, we find students outside Trafford filling up slots in its grammar schools, thus having a direct effect on local high school placements.”
It goes on: “Despite paying premiums associated with living in an education hub, we find our child assigned to a school in Partington, significantly distant and less convenient. Notably, none of our five favourable preferences were granted – a circumstance that has left us concerned if our voice is even being heard.”
She said that school assignments ‘should be just, fair and factor in the convenience and proximity to students’ homes’.
“The current system, unfortunately, potentially gives preference to students applying from outside catchment areas, snubbing deserving children who live locally.”
Lisa Marie added: “I urge Trafford council to explore immediate solutions, including the possibility of additional ‘bulge classes’—a measure that has been implemented in the past to accommodate increased local demand. Furthermore, Altrincham College is currently undergoing expansion. Has this been considered as a potential resolution?”
Other parents included Helen Brown, 47, Lisa Grimshaw, 37, Brendan Williams, 46, and Suganya Kumaravelu, 38.
Another parent said: “We have now to go through the arduous process of making separate appeals for each of our five preferences. It’s an awful situation.”
Meanwhile, Mr Rand told the LDRS: “As a dad with a young son, I understand the anger and concern parents have about the issues with school places locally. They should have the chance for their children to be educated in an appropriate school close to where they live, rather than a school that would take almost two hours to get to on public transport.
A spokesperson for Trafford council said: “This year, 93pc of Trafford parents were offered places at one of their top three choices.
“Unfortunately, places for schools in Sale were oversubscribed and, as in previous years, we provided Sale residents with tailored application advice to give themselves the best chance of achieving a local place.
“Due to the levels of oversubscription in Sale, a small number of applicants, some of whom had followed all of our advice regarding their application, could not be offered a place at a local school. They were subsequently offered a place at a school in a different area. We understand parents’ frustrations and have provided advice about the appeals process.”
“I’m organising a meeting with affected parents to hear their concerns, and I’ll be writing to Ashton-on-Mersey school about expanding the number of places they offer, and to local grammar schools about their admissions policy. I continue to support active efforts to increase secondary school provision in the area. “