'Wholly inadequate': Council responds to independent audit into 4 ‘cruise liner’ warehouses
A council has responded further to an independent audit which described a pre-application consultation for four ‘cruise liner’ warehouses as ‘wholly inadequate’.
On Thursday, Wigan council’s cabinet accepted the independent audit report of the planning process for the Astley Business Park development in Tyldesley. Planning permission for the site, which has been earmarked for development since 2006 and is not green belt land, was approved in June 2024.
Several residents, some of whom have gardens just 30 metres from the 350,000 sq ft logistics site, criticised the huge scale and appearance of the ‘towering warehouses’. Incidents of flooding on nearby paths and gardens have also occurred over the winter with complaints that run off from the construction site was causing the issues.
The audit concluded planning permission was granted in line with national and local legislation and procedures. However, it said that the developer, PLP, gave residents ‘no meaningful opportunity’ to engage with the proposals before a planning application was submitted.
The audit was commissioned by Wigan council and undertaken by POS Enterprises following numerous complaints from residents during construction. PLP have said their approach to engagement with the local community was agreed in advance with Wigan Council and they contacted more than 200 residents.


The council said the report does identify some areas for ‘learning’ to increase transparency in the planning process. These include site visits for major applications and a requirement for agents or developers to advise the local planning authority as to what their consultation consists of.
Speaking on behalf of the council, Coun Paul Prescott, said: “The independent audit report, commissioned by this cabinet, has found that planning permission was granted in line with national and local legislation and procedures.
“All committee members were fully briefed and trained. It notes a broader consultation would have been unlikely to raise any new or different planning consideration and that the consultation was in line with statutory requirements.
“Consultation prior to submission is at the behest of the developer. National policy explicitly prevents councils from mandating that such consultation happens or controlling the form that it takes.
“As a learning organisation, there are a number of actions that we will take in future, for example, regarding site visits for major applications. While not a statutory requirement, we will also require agents or developers to advise the local planning authority as to what their local consultation consists of.”


Campaign group Astley Warehouses Action Group, representatives of which were interviewed during the audit, said the findings echo concerns they had raised.
A spokesperson for the group said: “The report identified serious failings in consultation and transparency. We will continue to seek accountability and clear answers on how this development was handled and on the issues residents are still living with as a result.”
A spokesperson for PLP said: “PLP acknowledges the findings of the independent report and in particular the conclusion that the planning permission a granted was consistent with national and local legislation and procedures.
“As a responsible developer PLP contacted over 200 local residents about the plans as part of the planning process, and met with local councillors and other stakeholders to discuss the proposals. Furthermore, our approach to engagement with the local community was agreed in advance with Wigan Council.
“The scheme proposals evolved significantly and were improved as a result of this engagement. PLP will continue to work constructively with all stakeholders as the project moves forward, and we look forward to welcoming the first occupier to the scheme, bringing jobs and investment to the area.”
