'Jumping the gun': Planning committee flooding and traffic fears over new 155-home scheme

Some on Trafford’s planning committee feared they were “jumping the gun” when they gave their stamp of approval to a 155-home scheme.

The new housing is now one step closer to being built on farmland in the area known as New Carrington after councillors said it could go ahead subject to one final sign off from the Environment Agency (EA).

The approval came despite wide-ranging fears from elected members over flooding, traffic, environmental impacts and whether promised cash for the area will be forthcoming. The plan left those judging it torn, with calls for it to be approved, refused and for a decision to be deferred all being made at various points of last night’s (Thursday, January 22) debate. 

One of the key concerns raised by elected members was that they were being asked to make a decision before the EA said whether it was happy with the scheme. The organisation was in the process of reviewing a report from developer Redrow on the potential flood risks of building on the land.

The possible impact on the roads in the area also remained a lingering worry after the authority’s highways team advised the scheme would “worsen already severe impacts at both the Banky Lane junction and the Manchester Road/Moss Lane junctions”. This in turn runs the risk of increasing “the risk of collision” and creating “unreliable public transport” in the area, they had warned. 

Planning officers had acknowledged there would be a period of increased congestion, but argued mitigation of the impacts already formed part of the wider plan for New Carrington and Redow had agreed to contribute £6.3 million to those works. 

Coun Meena Minnis said: “I don’t like the fact that we are preempting something. The Environment Agency is objecting […] Alarm bells are ringing, why are we jumping the gun? 

New-build properties require local authority permission before work can begin. For planning queries, contact the council in your area.placeholder image
New-build properties require local authority permission before work can begin. For planning queries, contact the council in your area.

“Normally we would have the reports back and we would have dealt with all the concerns of other parties like Highways and the Environment Agency. We would deal with all of that first before we brought it to planning committee.” She added: “It will flood. We’ve seen that flooding is increasing.”

Councillor Phil Eckersley said he was uncomfortable with the proposed schedule for the financial contributions which match stages of occupation. He added he wanted to see some of the cash handed over before work started on site, saying the authority was not “guaranteed” to get the money otherwise.

Others on the committee said they were impressed by the plan, however. 

Councillor Shirley Proctor said: “There’s homes there that I would happily move into. I’m going to be voting for this application because I think, on balance, it’s a good plan.” She added she did not believe there was a risk of flooding on the site due to its design.” Councillor Hassan added: “We need more development. We need more houses.”

A motion was put forward to delay the decision on the plan until lingering concerns could be addressed. However, this was voted down by the committee. 

Ultimately, councillors opted to give officers power to approve the scheme subject to the EA withdrawing their objection after its final checks are complete. Should the EA maintain its objection, the application will return to the committee for final judgement.

The scheme was one of two submitted last year by Redrow Homes for fields between Partington and Warburton village. Between them, the proposals would see 558 new homes built off Warburton Lane.

New Carrington, which includes large swathes of Sale West and central and east Partington, forms part of Greater Manchester’s development plan up until 2039. It will ultimately see around 5,000 homes built in the area.

Related topics:
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice